Completely agree. Fact that Ukr has expanded the draft pool to old men, children as young as 16, and women is pure desperation. It's Germany circa 1945, just before the end. Add to that the demands for neighboring states to round up all military age Ukro refugees and extradite back to the loving embrace of the meat grinder is telling as well.
thanks Richard, judging from the UKR surrender videos I've seen you are likely on the money with your stats. The Russians should demand surrender soon, and, if UKR doesn't, go full blown war on them.
If they don't, they die when they return to duty and get hit again. With 40-90 percent losses per unit, I find it hard to believe that return to duty ameliorates the losses much.
Richard Steven Hack, Thank you for the thoroughness & referencing of your report & data.
1/2 million KIA, whole generation of Ukrainian men, killed & millions injured, is western Oligarch grudge-punishment-payback to particularly western Ukraine for its 1939 participation as part of the Axis war coalition of 12 nations against the western imperialist powers & Russia's centrally controlled western installed (Read Antony Sutton on 'Wall-Street & the Bolshevik Revolution) fake 'communism'. This 40 year old justified Soviet resentment was fed upon by CIA, Nuland, Freeland, Hunter-Biden & other operatives with over 15 billion $ to destabilize democratically elected President Yanukovych Ukraine. Just more dead bodies for insatiable western Oligarch war-mongering perverts.
GIVEN ALL OLIGARCH-LED-PUTSCH UKRAINE CIVIL BREAKDOWN FACTORS
Since the beginning, even Zelensky's fake 'peace' Presidential candidature, the vast majority of Ukrainians don't support the war. Out of 45 million Uke population pre 2014, over 20 million have fled the nation, mostly to Russia. Ukraine doesn't presently have fully functional operational civil infrastructure or essential-service administrations in most places. The now huge many 10s of 1000s contingent of foreign-language mercenaries are cell-phone dependent GPS geo-location targets in the largely wireless open-information-systems war. Russia is very astute in deliberate targeting foreign interference in the Minsk agreement UN mandated SVO. Even meathead foreign mercenaries are waking up to their one-sided one-way ill-informed propaganda ticket. If only the western public would convert Social Media from MONO-TO-DIALOGUE. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/1-communication-converting-social-media-from-mono-to-dialogue-libya
Europe without Nord-stream 2 is starving for energy & deindustrializing, Germany, France & Italy not by citizen choice. EU leaders are beginning to realize this is a western Oligarch putsch against Europe. Poland's switch is a key indicator. Americans, Canadians, Brits & Australians don't realize yet that; we are a disposable empire to our Oligarch masters, who have much greater digital, virus, mRNA gene & other command & control plans. These Oli plans will never be completely realized, because our very inefficient fragile centrally controlled, foreign extraction & exploitation economies are based in $$ & military dominance & ultimately very small 5% leverage fidelity margins.
Russia will control all majority Russian speaking southern (all Black sea) & eastern (all adjacent to Russia) Oblasts of Ukraine by the end of November 2023. My own estimation for Zelensky, Pravy-sektor, Svoboda & Azov leaders fleeing or being disposed from their offices in significant numbers with transfer of government completed by the end of December 2023.
Zelensky as a duo-national with loyalties elsewhere, is just playing one more assigned song & dance role, in having his people deliberately murdered for his Oligarch masters. Same act for B&H Biden, Boris Johnson, Merkel, Trudeau & other Oli-puppets.
We've all been Institutionally indoctrinated in Oligarch Monologue madness to be submissive colluders, for 7000 years of Oligarch fake top-down 'money' (Greek 'mnemosis' = 'memory') command & control. USA is just the next in the always economically & ecologically failing 'exogenous' (Latin 'other-generated') colonial empire. Humanity needs to recall our ancient economically inclusive, welcoming RELATIONAL ECONOMY. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/c-relational-economy
REUNITING: All people everywhere unite by recognizing each person's intellectual value in recalling our ancient worldwide 'indigenous' traditions of both-sided, equal-time, recorded & published COUNCIL-PROCESS. When we open ourselves to discussing all issues of our day-to-day relations, with our fellows, even within our marriages, we then develop working agreements & achieve conflict resolution together. We can then demand to hear Both-sides-now from media, education, religion, government, business, institutions & commerce. Just as India’s ‘Swadeshi’ (Hindi ‘indigenous’ aka ‘self-sufficiency’) economic movement, Mohandas Gandhi facilitated such Dialogue as ‘Satyagraha’ (H. ‘truth-search’) in bringing together individuals & leaders among India’s diverse economies, castes, religions, politics to speak reciprocally together in publishing dialectic (both-sided) statements as a unifier for India’s ‘Swaraj’ (H. ‘Self-rule’) for creating Constructive Agreement & Conflict Resolution. Socrates employed 'dialectics' ('both-sided') dialogue/'debate' (French 'de' = 'undo' + 'bate' = 'the-fight') for real 'education' (L. 'educare' = 'to-lead-forth-from-within') as the foundation of Academia (Athens garden of Academus). "Non-violence springs from love, cowardice from hate. Non-violence always suffers, cowardice would always inflict suffering. Non-violence & cowardice go ill together. I can imagine a fully armed man to be at heart a COWARD." Gandhi is speaking here to the intelligent mind of the soldier as a potentially active contributor (instead of intellectual coward) to his or her community, society & ultimately to the international conversation of war & peace such as Social Media might afford today if converted from Mono to Dialogue? https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/1-both-sides-now-equal-time-recorded-dialogues
Denis, From the pace of present events such as Zelensky's December 2023 rejection by US puppet Congress, my end of November 2023 prediction for Russian majority speaking Ukraine's Southern & Eastern Oblasts sovereign full restoration by now middle of January 2024 including Odessa is about 6 weeks too early.
Western Oligarch installed CIA / Mi6-SiS puppet Zelensky, Pravy Secktor, Svoboda & Azov battalion's fragmentation & ouster as Western Ukraine's ruling class should be complete by end of February 2024.
What a painful period with so much Oligarch precipitated death, injury & life-essential civil infrastructure destruction, since the fake Orange Revolution, Maidan & then Massacres leading up to the UN mandated Minsk accords for Ukrainians & Russians to be so manipulated by western hate-Oligarchs. As long as western 'exogenous' (Latin 'other-generated') Oligarch colonized society is so indoctrinated, submissive & controlled, by default we continue to finance & act as the arms & legs of their world atrocities.
If the "Ukraine as an expendable military tool wielded vs. Russia" operation collapses, is it not likely that our masters will throw their gain of function biolab resources out of the containment facilities and into the local streets as a spoiling move.
Anything is possible. My guess is if that stuff exists any longer in Ukraine and is released, Russia will isolate the troops exposed, come up with an effective way to deal with it, and most of Ukraine's population will reap the results, i.e., die. Then Russia will find a way to inoculate against it, move in and take Ukraine without any more shots fired. Another big lose for the West.
Here's the bottom line: Neither Ukraine, the US nor NATO combined can beat Russia short of launching nuclear WWIII. And even then, depending on how well the Russian air defense works against ICBM and IRBMs - and reputedly it works well - it is the US and EU that will bear the most costs, given that neither of them have any air defense which can defend against current Russian ICBMs or hypersonic missiles.
For instance, Russia just extended the range of one of its missiles to at least 6,500km with a potential for 8,000km, which means a Russian bomber can hit anywhere in northwestern US (roughly Washington to Montana and Wyoming - where the US missile silos are) while still inside Russian airspace, and with 8,000km, hit anywhere in the US. The US is utterly defenseless against this.
> This is why it's important to consider those non-BDA strikes in the daily total. And almost no one but me appears to do that. This is why people consistently underestimate the number of Ukrainian casualties.
Completely agree. Fact that Ukr has expanded the draft pool to old men, children as young as 16, and women is pure desperation. It's Germany circa 1945, just before the end. Add to that the demands for neighboring states to round up all military age Ukro refugees and extradite back to the loving embrace of the meat grinder is telling as well.
thanks Richard, judging from the UKR surrender videos I've seen you are likely on the money with your stats. The Russians should demand surrender soon, and, if UKR doesn't, go full blown war on them.
regarding the WIA numbers, do you account for the woeful at best medical system of Ukraine?
Do they eventually die after the fact and compilation of the Clobber List?
If they don't, they die when they return to duty and get hit again. With 40-90 percent losses per unit, I find it hard to believe that return to duty ameliorates the losses much.
It will take generations to outgrow the psychological wound (a more long-lasting detriment to Ukraine than death).
A good analysis. I am more and more inclining to your view of the metrics.
Richard Steven Hack, Thank you for the thoroughness & referencing of your report & data.
1/2 million KIA, whole generation of Ukrainian men, killed & millions injured, is western Oligarch grudge-punishment-payback to particularly western Ukraine for its 1939 participation as part of the Axis war coalition of 12 nations against the western imperialist powers & Russia's centrally controlled western installed (Read Antony Sutton on 'Wall-Street & the Bolshevik Revolution) fake 'communism'. This 40 year old justified Soviet resentment was fed upon by CIA, Nuland, Freeland, Hunter-Biden & other operatives with over 15 billion $ to destabilize democratically elected President Yanukovych Ukraine. Just more dead bodies for insatiable western Oligarch war-mongering perverts.
GIVEN ALL OLIGARCH-LED-PUTSCH UKRAINE CIVIL BREAKDOWN FACTORS
Since the beginning, even Zelensky's fake 'peace' Presidential candidature, the vast majority of Ukrainians don't support the war. Out of 45 million Uke population pre 2014, over 20 million have fled the nation, mostly to Russia. Ukraine doesn't presently have fully functional operational civil infrastructure or essential-service administrations in most places. The now huge many 10s of 1000s contingent of foreign-language mercenaries are cell-phone dependent GPS geo-location targets in the largely wireless open-information-systems war. Russia is very astute in deliberate targeting foreign interference in the Minsk agreement UN mandated SVO. Even meathead foreign mercenaries are waking up to their one-sided one-way ill-informed propaganda ticket. If only the western public would convert Social Media from MONO-TO-DIALOGUE. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/1-communication-converting-social-media-from-mono-to-dialogue-libya
Europe without Nord-stream 2 is starving for energy & deindustrializing, Germany, France & Italy not by citizen choice. EU leaders are beginning to realize this is a western Oligarch putsch against Europe. Poland's switch is a key indicator. Americans, Canadians, Brits & Australians don't realize yet that; we are a disposable empire to our Oligarch masters, who have much greater digital, virus, mRNA gene & other command & control plans. These Oli plans will never be completely realized, because our very inefficient fragile centrally controlled, foreign extraction & exploitation economies are based in $$ & military dominance & ultimately very small 5% leverage fidelity margins.
Humanity needs to reassert its distributed human intelligence through ECONOMIC DEMOCRACY as all our worldwide 'indigenous' (Latin 'self-generating') ancestors once enjoyed. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/c-relational-economy/8-economic-democracy
Russia will control all majority Russian speaking southern (all Black sea) & eastern (all adjacent to Russia) Oblasts of Ukraine by the end of November 2023. My own estimation for Zelensky, Pravy-sektor, Svoboda & Azov leaders fleeing or being disposed from their offices in significant numbers with transfer of government completed by the end of December 2023.
Zelensky as a duo-national with loyalties elsewhere, is just playing one more assigned song & dance role, in having his people deliberately murdered for his Oligarch masters. Same act for B&H Biden, Boris Johnson, Merkel, Trudeau & other Oli-puppets.
We've all been Institutionally indoctrinated in Oligarch Monologue madness to be submissive colluders, for 7000 years of Oligarch fake top-down 'money' (Greek 'mnemosis' = 'memory') command & control. USA is just the next in the always economically & ecologically failing 'exogenous' (Latin 'other-generated') colonial empire. Humanity needs to recall our ancient economically inclusive, welcoming RELATIONAL ECONOMY. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/c-relational-economy
REUNITING: All people everywhere unite by recognizing each person's intellectual value in recalling our ancient worldwide 'indigenous' traditions of both-sided, equal-time, recorded & published COUNCIL-PROCESS. When we open ourselves to discussing all issues of our day-to-day relations, with our fellows, even within our marriages, we then develop working agreements & achieve conflict resolution together. We can then demand to hear Both-sides-now from media, education, religion, government, business, institutions & commerce. Just as India’s ‘Swadeshi’ (Hindi ‘indigenous’ aka ‘self-sufficiency’) economic movement, Mohandas Gandhi facilitated such Dialogue as ‘Satyagraha’ (H. ‘truth-search’) in bringing together individuals & leaders among India’s diverse economies, castes, religions, politics to speak reciprocally together in publishing dialectic (both-sided) statements as a unifier for India’s ‘Swaraj’ (H. ‘Self-rule’) for creating Constructive Agreement & Conflict Resolution. Socrates employed 'dialectics' ('both-sided') dialogue/'debate' (French 'de' = 'undo' + 'bate' = 'the-fight') for real 'education' (L. 'educare' = 'to-lead-forth-from-within') as the foundation of Academia (Athens garden of Academus). "Non-violence springs from love, cowardice from hate. Non-violence always suffers, cowardice would always inflict suffering. Non-violence & cowardice go ill together. I can imagine a fully armed man to be at heart a COWARD." Gandhi is speaking here to the intelligent mind of the soldier as a potentially active contributor (instead of intellectual coward) to his or her community, society & ultimately to the international conversation of war & peace such as Social Media might afford today if converted from Mono to Dialogue? https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/1-both-sides-now-equal-time-recorded-dialogues
Excellent.
Denis, From the pace of present events such as Zelensky's December 2023 rejection by US puppet Congress, my end of November 2023 prediction for Russian majority speaking Ukraine's Southern & Eastern Oblasts sovereign full restoration by now middle of January 2024 including Odessa is about 6 weeks too early.
Western Oligarch installed CIA / Mi6-SiS puppet Zelensky, Pravy Secktor, Svoboda & Azov battalion's fragmentation & ouster as Western Ukraine's ruling class should be complete by end of February 2024.
What a painful period with so much Oligarch precipitated death, injury & life-essential civil infrastructure destruction, since the fake Orange Revolution, Maidan & then Massacres leading up to the UN mandated Minsk accords for Ukrainians & Russians to be so manipulated by western hate-Oligarchs. As long as western 'exogenous' (Latin 'other-generated') Oligarch colonized society is so indoctrinated, submissive & controlled, by default we continue to finance & act as the arms & legs of their world atrocities.
All humanity's 'indigenous' (L. 'self-generating') system is based in interdisciplinary checks & balances referred to worldwide as the INDIGENOUS CIRCLE-of-LIFE. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/a-home/3-indigenous-circle-of-life
Thanks for the information, Douglas. I'll read the indigenous circle of life.
If the "Ukraine as an expendable military tool wielded vs. Russia" operation collapses, is it not likely that our masters will throw their gain of function biolab resources out of the containment facilities and into the local streets as a spoiling move.
Anything is possible. My guess is if that stuff exists any longer in Ukraine and is released, Russia will isolate the troops exposed, come up with an effective way to deal with it, and most of Ukraine's population will reap the results, i.e., die. Then Russia will find a way to inoculate against it, move in and take Ukraine without any more shots fired. Another big lose for the West.
Here's the bottom line: Neither Ukraine, the US nor NATO combined can beat Russia short of launching nuclear WWIII. And even then, depending on how well the Russian air defense works against ICBM and IRBMs - and reputedly it works well - it is the US and EU that will bear the most costs, given that neither of them have any air defense which can defend against current Russian ICBMs or hypersonic missiles.
For instance, Russia just extended the range of one of its missiles to at least 6,500km with a potential for 8,000km, which means a Russian bomber can hit anywhere in northwestern US (roughly Washington to Montana and Wyoming - where the US missile silos are) while still inside Russian airspace, and with 8,000km, hit anywhere in the US. The US is utterly defenseless against this.
> This is why it's important to consider those non-BDA strikes in the daily total. And almost no one but me appears to do that. This is why people consistently underestimate the number of Ukrainian casualties.
It happens. :) If it'll make you feel any better, you're not the only one with these problems: https://web.archive.org/web/20230612175343/https://becomingbelte.rs/blog/10/overflowing-of-nova-kakhovka-dam