thanks richard... you have a statement backwards.. go re-read scott ritters commentary on this for reference... it is the left hand that is unsanitary, not the right... people in muslim countries eat with their right hand and wipe there ass with their left...
"with the “unclean” right hand when it should have been executed with the left hand."
i do believe the amaq news agency is a front for the cia-m16, or have some type of direct relationship with them, thus one is unlikely to find out who the people are at amaq news agency.. that ukraine was involved in this, there is no doubt, but being able to prove it is more difficult.. i too hope russia is able to do it.. it wouldn't be beyond the realm of possibility for sloppy work on their part... thanks for this post.. i think it's a very important issue that finding the source for would be extremely helpful.. if it can be shown without doubt, ukraines involvement - it will be hard ( but not impossible ) for the west to continue to deny and falsify what is actually driving ukraine in all of this..
You're undoubtedly right about the hands, I went from memory on that one. Oh, well, we can't get everything right. After all, one hand or the other, the terrorists got it wrong, too. :-)
Richard Steven Hack, Thank you for your thorough research. Excellent analysis on all points & the starting point of Scott Ritters True North statement, which I read on 27Mar’24. https://www.scottritterextra.com/p/true-north
Your assessment of the order of events & actors have much merit. Thanks to Russia & such as Putin for having the human compassion to have real 'intelligence' on Crocus, Concert & what is happening today.
CAUGHT IN A 'REACTIVE' MODE
Even as I write here, western 'exogenous' (Latin 'other-generated') OLIGARCH owned & commanded cabal fake-democracy Nations (USA, Canada, Britain, France, Belgium, Netherlands) have many billions of $$ & years of plotting for the next dozen terrorists attacks to be rolled out over the next year. Once these Oligarch directed atrocities are committed, we spend the next decades trying to figure them out, always a million steps in arrears.
INDIGENOUS TRUTH & RECONCILIATION
Most of us have never had access to all humanity's worldwide 'Indigenous' (L. 'Self-generating') heritage of Peace & Prosperity. With each conquest such as in Palestine today, the Americas, Africa & worldwide, western colonizing Oligarchs quickly had to erase the foundational life-instructional indigenous narratives & impose sick myths, lies & distortions.
RESOLVING ISSUES BEFORE THEY HAPPEN
All humanity's worldwide 'indigenous' ancestors cultivated constant communication formally through this process of COUNCIL PROCESS for creating Understanding, Constructive Agreements, Working Contracts & Conflict Resolution. These Dialectic Rights culturally provided that every person could call for formal dialogues with anyone they’re affected by in words or actions. Modalities include grouping of 'debates' (French 'de' = 'undo' + 'bate' = 'the-fight') within Stakeholder groups to choose Spokespersons. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/1-both-sides-now-equal-time-recorded-dialogues
All humanity's indigenous ancestors kept ahead in humane relations by cultivating COUNCIL-PROCESS or Both-Sides-Now, Equal-time, Recorded & Published Dialogues at all levels of human society among friends, family, extended-family, the ~100 (50-150) person Multihome-Dwelling-Complex (eg. Longhouse-apartment, Pueblo-townhouse & Kanata-village), Cities, Regions, Nations, Confederacies & Continental Councils).
Through maintaining a culture of openness or as Socrates in his organization of Academic (Athens 'Garden-of-Academus') 'education' (L. 'educare' = 'to-lead-forth-from-within') refers to Dialectic-Rights for every person to raise issues among his or her fellows to be addressed in private or public dialogues, issues are then resolved at their primary levels of interaction, appropriately.
Mohandas Gandhi helped create UNITY IN INDIA'S DIVERSITY through bringing together leaders of India's religions, economic-castes, political parties into formal 'SATYAGRAHA' (Hindi 'Truth-search') consisting of Both-sided, Equal-time, recorded & published Dialogues. Gandhi was hoping for Winston Churchill & Adolf Hitler to engage, but Churchill blocked this communication. We can understand this reluctance as INTELLECTUAL COWARDICE starting at the top, well spread at all levels, but resolvable at all levels, by any 2 people. Human mind is essentially 'Dialectic' ('Both-sided') in the way we process & incorporate information, so such dialogues are very attractive to us all.
Today's top-down Oligarch directed colonial institutions of fake Finance, Media, Religion, Education, Military-Industrial, Legislative, Judicial, Pharma-med & Agri-business are inappropriately scaled in Oligarch hierarchal structures so as never to get to the detailed human nature of issues, events & relationships.
ECONOMIC MEMORY with bodily autonomy. Modern neurology has established how each part has both neurons, memory, intelligence & the autonomous mandate to act with their specific knowledge. The brain is considered as one of several body Nexus for the inter-communication of these events & coordinated action by the whole body, most often learning of events & actions, well after the fact. The human body is analogous as a model for humanity's body-politic or society at various levels. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/3-economic-memory
I tend to agree with your take on social communication. But let's never forget that humans are primates with a hierarchical social structure oriented around alphas, beta, probers, and omegas. This sabotages the species' ability to organize beyond the tribal level. While this hasn't stopped the species from developing a civilization, and more importantly technology, it's severely hampered it.
There are other aspects as well flowing from the inadequately evolved brain.
Fortunately all of this can be corrected with further technological development. - if the species doesn't use current or further technology to destroy its civilization.
RichardSteven, i can understand the colonial anthropology you are coming from, but is better to keep an open mind on other possibilities over a much longer time-frame. I spent time with Jane Goodall, not as a fan in every regard, but sufficiently impressed with her Chimpanzee communications. In our institutionally propaganda & censor controlled world, few people have had exposure to their own very ancient, indigenous heritage.
I find myself with now 60 of my 71 years in solidarity involvement with 1st Nations & worldwide indigenous peoples. As you can see, I divide human history into the Oligarch commanded institutional propaganda 'exogenous' (Latin 'other-generated') period of the past 7000 years since Babylon & the many 10s of 1000s of years of peaceful & abundant indigenous (L. 'self-generating') heritage. Indigenous heritage has a host of provisions found in every nation, every confederacy, on every continent & island such as described worldwide in the INDIGENOUS-CIRCLE-of-LIFE, which provided checks & balances for every function over many 10s of 1000s of years of vibrant, abundant, distributed wealth in loving societies. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/a-home/3-indigenous-circle-of-life
3 COMPONENTS OF THE INDIGENOUS GREAT-GOOD-WAY-OF-KINDNESS
2) time-based equivalency accounting on the String-shell Value System (eg. Wampum across Turtle-Island/N. America, Quipu for S. America & Cowrie in indigenous Celtic-Slavic Europe, Asia, Africa, Australia & all islands. Progressive ownership is grouped in collective Domestic, industrial & Commercial Production-Society-Guilds with accounting specialists. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/c-relational-economy & Council Process,
3) 3-D Polyculture Orchards being 100 fold (10,000%) more productive of food, materials, energy & water-cycle, among a host of other universal commonalities.
INDIGENOUS IS ABSOLUTELY SCALEABLE The indigenous 350,000 person Tenochtitlan (Mexico-City in 1620 was the largest city in the world built on an artificial island in the middle of Lake Texcoco. Cortez as a violent murderous invader was shocked upon traversing one of Tenochtitlan's Causeway bridges, how the water was clean & drinkable. Turtle-Island / North America had some 110 nations organized into 25-30 Confederacies with Council-Process at every level.
It's not "colonial anthropology" - it's evolutionary genetics. Humans are primates and primate behavior is the core of human behavior. And the divisions in behavior I mentioned come not only from primates, but from many other mammalian species. This is as I say the core of behavior on an evolutionary level. So it existed in prior indigenous societies as well.
I agree that prior to conventional "civilization", humans worked well in tribal contexts. But there's a difference between a 350,000 and an eight billion civilization. As Stalin said, "Quantity has a quality all its own."
Nothing is going to change until the basic human structure of the brain and body are changed. Fortunately that is coming.
BASICS OF BRAIN FUNCTION. My mother was a head nurse at the Montreal Neurological Institute to Dr. Wilder Penfield, who in the 1930s established the first Neurological mapping of Brain & Body corresponding functions. The web-section on Economic Memory above, analogous to both human body & society function, best describes Autonomous organization of both with changes in perspective both in Neurology & in Society.
I referred to just One city Tenochtitlan with 350,000 people, as the world's largest city in 1520, indigenous or exogenous. Colonial Anthropology, of which I have taken an active research part in, has hugely under-calculated the numbers of people living in plenty during indigenous periods. Ethnohistory by such as Petr Kropotkin 'Mutual-Aid', Lewis-Henry Morgan in Ancient Society & Henry F. Dobyns, Their Number-become-thinned' are excellent guides to indigenous integrated quantity & quality, way beyond what you have been indoctrination-imagined to believe. Here is some of my work working with 1st Nations compiling 1st Nation Placenames across our Tiohtiake Montreal Urban region as a guild to Sustainability Rooted in Heritage under the auspices of McGill University's Dept of Geography.
https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/a-home/5-mapping-ecological-indigenous-heritage My Anthropology & Archaeology professor friends describe the Urban Placename mapping as something which would be a career ender for themselves at Universities & other schools which only get government, institutional & corporate funding for keeping the glorious Colonial Settler myth alive as supposedly 'Brave' pioneers. The reality is that settlers were insecure Refugees from Oligarch mismanagement in Europe fleeing war, failed economy & destroyed ecologies.
What you call 'tribal' is an empire pejorative, which doesn't mathematically 'compute' or economically understand the Cultural 'Fractal' ('fraction, multiplier, building-block, where-the-part-contains-the-whole') local & even hemispheric organization of humanity's indigenous ancestors.
Lev Davidovich Bronstein (Trotsky) hired by New York Stock Exchange Jacob Schiff & Vladimir Lenin hired by Germany's Financier Warburg delivered Stalin & his false 'co-operatives' (L 'co' = 'together' + 'operatives' = 'stakeholders') as a product of western desire to economically collapse Russia. Schiff & Warburg as collaborators, were successful, but it took 3 generations for Russians & the Soviet sphere to become completely disillusioned with fake 'co-ops'). I spent 35 years working in fake co-ops, as well as living & working with Russian Doukhobor, German Mennonite & English Quaker fake co-ops to understand from within.
Evolutionary Genetics are much longer than most people understand & most notably include what Petr Kropotkin describes in 'Mutual-Aid, a factor of evolution', written1902 as the most important factor in human evolution, going back way beyond the Oligarch commanded & controlled fake metal-coin 'money' (Greek 'mnemosis' = 'memory') exogenous period
We'll agree to disagree as much of what you're discussing is irrelevant to the current article. However, I found much of what you say is considerably interesting and no doubt will provide food for thought. Thanks for your comments.
Thank you for your responses. Again you analysis of the Crocus & Concert Hall Massacres is excellent.
Mossad's motto, "By the art of deception, thou shalt do war" describes the False-flag ISIS-K association which they are desperately trying to establish in the public mind & government policy.
DIVIDE & CONQUER in both Islam & particularly among Russia & China, with significant Muslim populations is a synergistic goal of the west's Oligarchy financed, armed & orchestrated massacres. At this Oligarch orchestrated juncture of Ukraine & Gaza, western cabal don't want Russia, China or India to intervene on behalf of Gazans being massacred. Our citizen task is to move from Reactive to Proactive analysis & involvement.
The way, the same colonial Oligarch financed & controlled Neurology or Anthropology, place design-limits on historical worldview, determine whether we each are disempowered observers or cultural animators.
Ominous signs point to a staged event while everyone else is on a wild goose chase. Look at the video footage. See anything unusual? Got that gut feeling something ain't right? Tick, tock.
thanks richard... you have a statement backwards.. go re-read scott ritters commentary on this for reference... it is the left hand that is unsanitary, not the right... people in muslim countries eat with their right hand and wipe there ass with their left...
"with the “unclean” right hand when it should have been executed with the left hand."
i do believe the amaq news agency is a front for the cia-m16, or have some type of direct relationship with them, thus one is unlikely to find out who the people are at amaq news agency.. that ukraine was involved in this, there is no doubt, but being able to prove it is more difficult.. i too hope russia is able to do it.. it wouldn't be beyond the realm of possibility for sloppy work on their part... thanks for this post.. i think it's a very important issue that finding the source for would be extremely helpful.. if it can be shown without doubt, ukraines involvement - it will be hard ( but not impossible ) for the west to continue to deny and falsify what is actually driving ukraine in all of this..
You're undoubtedly right about the hands, I went from memory on that one. Oh, well, we can't get everything right. After all, one hand or the other, the terrorists got it wrong, too. :-)
Richard Steven Hack, Thank you for your thorough research. Excellent analysis on all points & the starting point of Scott Ritters True North statement, which I read on 27Mar’24. https://www.scottritterextra.com/p/true-north
Your assessment of the order of events & actors have much merit. Thanks to Russia & such as Putin for having the human compassion to have real 'intelligence' on Crocus, Concert & what is happening today.
CAUGHT IN A 'REACTIVE' MODE
Even as I write here, western 'exogenous' (Latin 'other-generated') OLIGARCH owned & commanded cabal fake-democracy Nations (USA, Canada, Britain, France, Belgium, Netherlands) have many billions of $$ & years of plotting for the next dozen terrorists attacks to be rolled out over the next year. Once these Oligarch directed atrocities are committed, we spend the next decades trying to figure them out, always a million steps in arrears.
INDIGENOUS TRUTH & RECONCILIATION
Most of us have never had access to all humanity's worldwide 'Indigenous' (L. 'Self-generating') heritage of Peace & Prosperity. With each conquest such as in Palestine today, the Americas, Africa & worldwide, western colonizing Oligarchs quickly had to erase the foundational life-instructional indigenous narratives & impose sick myths, lies & distortions.
RESOLVING ISSUES BEFORE THEY HAPPEN
All humanity's worldwide 'indigenous' ancestors cultivated constant communication formally through this process of COUNCIL PROCESS for creating Understanding, Constructive Agreements, Working Contracts & Conflict Resolution. These Dialectic Rights culturally provided that every person could call for formal dialogues with anyone they’re affected by in words or actions. Modalities include grouping of 'debates' (French 'de' = 'undo' + 'bate' = 'the-fight') within Stakeholder groups to choose Spokespersons. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/1-both-sides-now-equal-time-recorded-dialogues
CONVERTING SOCIAL MEDIA FROM MONO TO DIALOGUE Implementing online Debate options in Chat rooms & Comment sections. 'Media' (L. 'medium' = 'middle' implying 'both-sides are expressed') implying the publishing of diverse points of view. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/1communication-converting-social-media-from-mono-to-dialogue-libya
All humanity's indigenous ancestors kept ahead in humane relations by cultivating COUNCIL-PROCESS or Both-Sides-Now, Equal-time, Recorded & Published Dialogues at all levels of human society among friends, family, extended-family, the ~100 (50-150) person Multihome-Dwelling-Complex (eg. Longhouse-apartment, Pueblo-townhouse & Kanata-village), Cities, Regions, Nations, Confederacies & Continental Councils).
Through maintaining a culture of openness or as Socrates in his organization of Academic (Athens 'Garden-of-Academus') 'education' (L. 'educare' = 'to-lead-forth-from-within') refers to Dialectic-Rights for every person to raise issues among his or her fellows to be addressed in private or public dialogues, issues are then resolved at their primary levels of interaction, appropriately.
Mohandas Gandhi helped create UNITY IN INDIA'S DIVERSITY through bringing together leaders of India's religions, economic-castes, political parties into formal 'SATYAGRAHA' (Hindi 'Truth-search') consisting of Both-sided, Equal-time, recorded & published Dialogues. Gandhi was hoping for Winston Churchill & Adolf Hitler to engage, but Churchill blocked this communication. We can understand this reluctance as INTELLECTUAL COWARDICE starting at the top, well spread at all levels, but resolvable at all levels, by any 2 people. Human mind is essentially 'Dialectic' ('Both-sided') in the way we process & incorporate information, so such dialogues are very attractive to us all.
Today's top-down Oligarch directed colonial institutions of fake Finance, Media, Religion, Education, Military-Industrial, Legislative, Judicial, Pharma-med & Agri-business are inappropriately scaled in Oligarch hierarchal structures so as never to get to the detailed human nature of issues, events & relationships.
ECONOMIC MEMORY with bodily autonomy. Modern neurology has established how each part has both neurons, memory, intelligence & the autonomous mandate to act with their specific knowledge. The brain is considered as one of several body Nexus for the inter-communication of these events & coordinated action by the whole body, most often learning of events & actions, well after the fact. The human body is analogous as a model for humanity's body-politic or society at various levels. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/d-participatory-structure/3-economic-memory
I tend to agree with your take on social communication. But let's never forget that humans are primates with a hierarchical social structure oriented around alphas, beta, probers, and omegas. This sabotages the species' ability to organize beyond the tribal level. While this hasn't stopped the species from developing a civilization, and more importantly technology, it's severely hampered it.
There are other aspects as well flowing from the inadequately evolved brain.
Fortunately all of this can be corrected with further technological development. - if the species doesn't use current or further technology to destroy its civilization.
RichardSteven, i can understand the colonial anthropology you are coming from, but is better to keep an open mind on other possibilities over a much longer time-frame. I spent time with Jane Goodall, not as a fan in every regard, but sufficiently impressed with her Chimpanzee communications. In our institutionally propaganda & censor controlled world, few people have had exposure to their own very ancient, indigenous heritage.
I find myself with now 60 of my 71 years in solidarity involvement with 1st Nations & worldwide indigenous peoples. As you can see, I divide human history into the Oligarch commanded institutional propaganda 'exogenous' (Latin 'other-generated') period of the past 7000 years since Babylon & the many 10s of 1000s of years of peaceful & abundant indigenous (L. 'self-generating') heritage. Indigenous heritage has a host of provisions found in every nation, every confederacy, on every continent & island such as described worldwide in the INDIGENOUS-CIRCLE-of-LIFE, which provided checks & balances for every function over many 10s of 1000s of years of vibrant, abundant, distributed wealth in loving societies. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/a-home/3-indigenous-circle-of-life
3 COMPONENTS OF THE INDIGENOUS GREAT-GOOD-WAY-OF-KINDNESS
1) The ~100 (50-150) person Multihome, where 70% of people live today as an intimate, intergenerational, female-male, interdisciplinary, critical-mass, economies-of-scale unit of collaboration. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/c-relational-economy/1-extending-our-welcome-participatory-multihome-cohousing
2) time-based equivalency accounting on the String-shell Value System (eg. Wampum across Turtle-Island/N. America, Quipu for S. America & Cowrie in indigenous Celtic-Slavic Europe, Asia, Africa, Australia & all islands. Progressive ownership is grouped in collective Domestic, industrial & Commercial Production-Society-Guilds with accounting specialists. https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/c-relational-economy & Council Process,
3) 3-D Polyculture Orchards being 100 fold (10,000%) more productive of food, materials, energy & water-cycle, among a host of other universal commonalities.
SYLVALIZATION (L. 'sylva' = 'tree') https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/design/1-indigenous-welcome-orchard-food-production-efficiencies
INDIGENOUS IS ABSOLUTELY SCALEABLE The indigenous 350,000 person Tenochtitlan (Mexico-City in 1620 was the largest city in the world built on an artificial island in the middle of Lake Texcoco. Cortez as a violent murderous invader was shocked upon traversing one of Tenochtitlan's Causeway bridges, how the water was clean & drinkable. Turtle-Island / North America had some 110 nations organized into 25-30 Confederacies with Council-Process at every level.
It's not "colonial anthropology" - it's evolutionary genetics. Humans are primates and primate behavior is the core of human behavior. And the divisions in behavior I mentioned come not only from primates, but from many other mammalian species. This is as I say the core of behavior on an evolutionary level. So it existed in prior indigenous societies as well.
I agree that prior to conventional "civilization", humans worked well in tribal contexts. But there's a difference between a 350,000 and an eight billion civilization. As Stalin said, "Quantity has a quality all its own."
Nothing is going to change until the basic human structure of the brain and body are changed. Fortunately that is coming.
BASICS OF BRAIN FUNCTION. My mother was a head nurse at the Montreal Neurological Institute to Dr. Wilder Penfield, who in the 1930s established the first Neurological mapping of Brain & Body corresponding functions. The web-section on Economic Memory above, analogous to both human body & society function, best describes Autonomous organization of both with changes in perspective both in Neurology & in Society.
I referred to just One city Tenochtitlan with 350,000 people, as the world's largest city in 1520, indigenous or exogenous. Colonial Anthropology, of which I have taken an active research part in, has hugely under-calculated the numbers of people living in plenty during indigenous periods. Ethnohistory by such as Petr Kropotkin 'Mutual-Aid', Lewis-Henry Morgan in Ancient Society & Henry F. Dobyns, Their Number-become-thinned' are excellent guides to indigenous integrated quantity & quality, way beyond what you have been indoctrination-imagined to believe. Here is some of my work working with 1st Nations compiling 1st Nation Placenames across our Tiohtiake Montreal Urban region as a guild to Sustainability Rooted in Heritage under the auspices of McGill University's Dept of Geography.
https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/a-home/5-tiohtiake-mohawk-placenames
https://sites.google.com/site/indigenecommunity/a-home/5-mapping-ecological-indigenous-heritage My Anthropology & Archaeology professor friends describe the Urban Placename mapping as something which would be a career ender for themselves at Universities & other schools which only get government, institutional & corporate funding for keeping the glorious Colonial Settler myth alive as supposedly 'Brave' pioneers. The reality is that settlers were insecure Refugees from Oligarch mismanagement in Europe fleeing war, failed economy & destroyed ecologies.
What you call 'tribal' is an empire pejorative, which doesn't mathematically 'compute' or economically understand the Cultural 'Fractal' ('fraction, multiplier, building-block, where-the-part-contains-the-whole') local & even hemispheric organization of humanity's indigenous ancestors.
Lev Davidovich Bronstein (Trotsky) hired by New York Stock Exchange Jacob Schiff & Vladimir Lenin hired by Germany's Financier Warburg delivered Stalin & his false 'co-operatives' (L 'co' = 'together' + 'operatives' = 'stakeholders') as a product of western desire to economically collapse Russia. Schiff & Warburg as collaborators, were successful, but it took 3 generations for Russians & the Soviet sphere to become completely disillusioned with fake 'co-ops'). I spent 35 years working in fake co-ops, as well as living & working with Russian Doukhobor, German Mennonite & English Quaker fake co-ops to understand from within.
Evolutionary Genetics are much longer than most people understand & most notably include what Petr Kropotkin describes in 'Mutual-Aid, a factor of evolution', written1902 as the most important factor in human evolution, going back way beyond the Oligarch commanded & controlled fake metal-coin 'money' (Greek 'mnemosis' = 'memory') exogenous period
We'll agree to disagree as much of what you're discussing is irrelevant to the current article. However, I found much of what you say is considerably interesting and no doubt will provide food for thought. Thanks for your comments.
Thank you for your responses. Again you analysis of the Crocus & Concert Hall Massacres is excellent.
Mossad's motto, "By the art of deception, thou shalt do war" describes the False-flag ISIS-K association which they are desperately trying to establish in the public mind & government policy.
DIVIDE & CONQUER in both Islam & particularly among Russia & China, with significant Muslim populations is a synergistic goal of the west's Oligarchy financed, armed & orchestrated massacres. At this Oligarch orchestrated juncture of Ukraine & Gaza, western cabal don't want Russia, China or India to intervene on behalf of Gazans being massacred. Our citizen task is to move from Reactive to Proactive analysis & involvement.
The way, the same colonial Oligarch financed & controlled Neurology or Anthropology, place design-limits on historical worldview, determine whether we each are disempowered observers or cultural animators.
Ominous signs point to a staged event while everyone else is on a wild goose chase. Look at the video footage. See anything unusual? Got that gut feeling something ain't right? Tick, tock.